查看完整版本: 看完集结号了

看完集结号了

真不错唉
又抹了三把鼻涕><

士兵突击的绝对壮烈版
七连解散了，只剩下一个士兵
九连打没了，只剩下一个连长
真真正正的尸山血海中爬起来的钢铁意志钢铁汉啊

感觉九连就是七连的前身...这样的联想应该很正常吧
集结号后面连长生活的延伸没想到,不过确实是出彩的部分

镜头血腥，孩子们看了不要留下阴影

题外话,突然想明白为啥国内电影不分级了...分级了就没爱国主义教育了:han2

me too

i dont know y so many people in the forums like mop or tianya hav so many BAD BAD BAD review on this film........................

it's really gooooooooooood moive and i was deeply touched by this one

BTW......i think I Am Legend is really goooooooooood too!!! I love the feel when i watched the moive- longly, depressed, and peaceful...............


-----------------

As i still think that the diamond ring is the key reason in Lust, Causion, i'v been wondering if i had a bad or strange taste of stories......LOL

[quote]原帖由 [i]那一片俗[/i] 于 2008-2-2 02:39 AM 发表
me too

i dont know y so many people in the forums like mop or tianya hav so many BAD BAD BAD review on this film........................

it's really gooooooooooood moive and i was deeply touc ... [/quote]



people always have reasons to make their arguments not so lame, just like you and I do right.heehee
so it's fine la~believe in yourself

[[i] 本帖最后由 marthanovera 于 2008-2-2 03:11 AM 编辑 [/i]]

btw, we think it's good, becuz we are still simple and good-natured, I think it's good. heh

[quote]原帖由 [i]marthanovera[/i] 于 2008-2-2 03:03 发表




people always have reasons to make their arguments not so lame, just like you and I do right.heehee
[color=Red]so it's fine la~believe in yourself [/color][/quote]


OK
i strongly insist that the diamond ring is the key reason of Jiazhi Wang's betrayal....!!!

我也是今晚刚刚看完。很不错的片子，有场面，有情节，有深度，没有明显的bug（我没看出来）。

不知道为啥说网上很多恶评？从12月份开始，我身边所有去电影院看过的人，无论男女都说集结号好看。

有个挺有意思的，历史上志愿军180师“师长郑其贵，副师长段龙章和参谋长王振邦都回来了”，集结号偏偏把那个下命令的团长编成180师副师长，死在朝鲜。似乎有点映射180师的悲惨遭遇。

I can't agree more! 看完全篇我的核心收获就是，女人是可以被一颗钻石瞬间击倒的。

[quote]原帖由 [i]那一片俗[/i] 于 2008-2-2 04:54 PM 发表



OK
i strongly insist that the diamond ring is the key reason of Jiazhi Wang's betrayal....!!! [/quote]

[quote]原帖由 [i]woody[/i] 于 2008-2-2 11:30 AM 发表
I can't agree more! 看完全篇我的核心收获就是，女人是可以被一颗钻石瞬间击倒的。

[/quote]
呵呵，别太关注表面现象
也许她是被那颗钻石击倒的
但更重要的是前面的感情build-up
那个时候，就算是他送她一颗雨花石，她一样也会被击倒的

As a starter, Assembly Horn is one of the few good movies in China that shows what war really is:

Not honor and glory, but sacrifice and destruction...on the other hand, there are times when sacrifice and destruction are necessary for a greater cause. Thus, it is not the victory or those "smart" military leaders that we should celebrate and glorify the most, but those who gave up their lives----because they deserved better.

This is a very modern/Western view of wars, and that is why the movie is quite unusual. Maybe it IS time for us Chinese to view wars with a solemn but determined attitude, instead of that revolutionary fervor that was always present in old movies. Objectively speaking, military leadership can only do so much as to reduce casualties in a war----the outcome of a large-scale war is already determined by the socio-political factors. For many years, as we all know, our propaganda-style Chinese media tended to overlook this truth and instead emphasize on on miracles of leadership. I think Assembly Horn is a step forward for us in this aspect, and I love it for this reason.

[quote]原帖由 [i]woody[/i] 于 2008-2-2 10:30 发表
I can't agree more! 看完全篇我的核心收获就是，女人是可以被一颗钻石瞬间击倒的。

[/quote]
:hand2:hand2:hand2

很多人不喜欢集结号的原因是作为一个军人，服从命令是天职，没有下命令要你撤，你就是不能撤，就是全牺牲了也不能撤，没什么好讨价还价的。解放军的传统如此，这是个反传统的片子

婚后的chao果然快成了妇女之友啦，哈哈
就是能够透过表面看本质


[quote]原帖由 [i]chao[/i] 于 2008-2-2 10:45 AM 发表

呵呵，别太关注表面现象
也许她是被那颗钻石击倒的
但更重要的是前面的感情build-up
那个时候，就算是他送她一颗雨花石，她一样也会被击倒的 [/quote]

[quote]原帖由 [i]freei[/i] 于 2008-2-2 03:59 PM 发表
婚后的chao果然快成了妇女之友啦，哈哈
就是能够透过表面看本质


[/quote]
:kao:。。。。只不过是逻辑推理而已